AN ESSAY on CRITICISM.
[34]'TIS hard to ſay, if greater want of ſkill
Appear in writing, or in judging ill;
But of the two, leſs dang'rous is th' offence
To tire our patience, than miſlead our ſenſe.
Some few in that, but numbers err in this,
Ten cenſure wrong, for one who writes amiſs.
A fool might once himſelf alone expoſe,
Now one in verſe makes many more in proſe.
'Tis with our judgments as our watches, none
Go juſt alike, yet each believes his own.
In poets as true genius is but rare,
True taſte as ſeldom is the critic's ſhare;
Both muſt alike from heav'n derive their light,
Theſe born to judge, as well as thoſe to write.
† Let ſuch teach others who themſelves excel,
And cenſure freely who have written well.
[36] Authors are partial to their wit, 'tis true;
But are not criticks to their judgment too?
Yet if we look more cloſely, we ſhall find,
† Moſt have the ſeeds of judgment in their mind:
Nature affords at leaſt a glimm'ring light;
The lines, tho' touch'd but faintly, are drawn right.
But as the ſlighteſt-ſketch, if juſtly trac'd,
Is by ill-colouring but the more diſgrac'd,
So by falſe learning is good ſenſe defac'd.
Some are bewilder'd in the maze of ſchools,
And ſome made coxcombs, nature meant but fools.
In ſearch of wit, thoſe loſe their common ſenſe,
And then turn criticks in their own defence.
Each burns alike, who can, or cannot write,
Or with a rival's, or an eunuch's ſpite.
All fools have ſtill an itching to deride,
And fain wou'd be upon the laughing ſide:
If Maevius ſcribble in Apollo's ſpight,
There are, who judge ſtill worſe than he can write.
Some have at firſt for wits, then poets paſt,
Turn'd criticks next, and prov'd plain fools at laſt.
Some neither can for wits or criticks paſs,
As heavy mules are neither horſe, nor aſs.
[38] Thoſe half-learn'd witlings num'rous in our iſle,
As half-form'd inſects on the banks of Nile,
Unfiniſh'd things one knows not what to call,
Their generation's ſo equivocal:
To tell 'em, wou'd a hundred tongues require,
Or one vain wit's, that might a hundred tire.
But you who ſeek to give and merit Fame,
And juſtly bear a critick's noble name,
Be ſure yourſelf and your own reach to know,
How far your genius, taſte, and learning go.
Launch not beyond your depth, but be diſcreet,
And mark that point where ſenſe and dulneſs meet.
Nature to all things fix'd the limits fit,
And wiſely curb'd proud man's pretending wit.
As on the land while here the ocean gains,
In other parts it leaves wide ſandy plains.
Thus in the ſoul, while memory prevails,
The ſolid pow'r of underſtanding fails;
Where beams of warm imagination play,
The memory's ſoft figures melt away.
One ſcience only will one genius fit;
So vaſt is art, ſo narrow human wit:
Not only bounded to peculiar arts,
But oft in thoſe confin'd to ſingle parts.
Like kings, we loſe the conqueſts gain'd before,
By vain ambition ſtill to make them more.
[40] Each might his ſeveral province well command,
Would all but ſtoop to what they underſtand.
Firſt follow Nature, and your judgment frame
By her juſt ſtandard, which is ſtill the ſame.
Unerring Nature, ſtill divinely bright,
One clear, unchang'd, and univerſal light,
Life, force, and beauty muſt to all impart,
At once the ſource, and end, and teſt of art.
Art from that fund each juſt ſupply provides,
Works without ſhow, and without pomp preſides:
In ſome fair body thus th' informing ſoul
With ſpirits feeds, with vigour fills the whole,
Each motion guides, and ev'ry nerve ſuſtains;
Itſelf unſeen, but in th' effect, remains.
There are whom heav'n has bleſt with ſtore of wit,
Yet want as much again to manage it;
For wit and judgment ever are at ſtrife,
Tho' meant each other's aid, like man and wife.
'Tis more to guide, than ſpur, the Muſe's ſteed;
Reſtrain his fury, than provoke his ſpeed;
The winged courſer, like a gen'rous horſe,
Shows moſt true Mettle when you check his courſe.
Thoſe rules of old diſcover'd, not devis'd,
Are Nature ſtill, but Nature methodiz'd:
[42] Nature, like monarchy, is but reſtrain'd
By the ſame laws, which firſt herſelf ordain'd.
Hear how learn'd Greece her uſeful rules indites,
When to ſuppreſs, and when indulge our flights!
High on Parnaſſus' top her ſons ſhe ſhow'd,
And pointed out thoſe arduous paths they trod,
Held from afar, aloft, th' immortal prize,
And urg'd the reſt by equal ſteps to riſe.
Juſt
† precepts thus from great examples giv'n,
She drew from them what they deriv'd from heav'n.
The generous critic fann'd the poet's fire,
And taught the world with reaſon to admire.
Then Criticiſm the Muſe's handmaid prov'd,
To dreſs her charms, and make her more belov'd:
But following wits from that intention ſtray'd:
Who could not win the miſtreſs woo'd the maid:
Againſt the poets their own arms they turn'd,
Sure to hate moſt the men from whom they learn'd.
So modern 'pothecaries taught the art,
By doctor's bills to play the doctor's part,
Bold in the practice of miſtaken rules,
Preſcribe, apply, and call their maſters fools.
Some on the leaves of ancient authors prey,
Nor time, nor moths e'er ſpoil'd ſo much as they.
[44] Some dryly plain, without invention's aid,
Write dull receipts how poems ſhould be made.
Theſe loſe the ſenſe their learning to diſplay,
And thoſe explain the meaning quite away.
You then whoſe judgment the right courſe wou'd ſteer,
Know well each Ancient's proper character,
His fable, ſubject, ſcope of ev'ry page,
Religion, country, genius of his age:
Without all theſe at once before your eyes,
Cavil you may, but never criticize
Be Homer's works your ſtudy and delight,
Read him by day and meditate by night.
Thence form your judgment, thence your notions bring,
And trace the Muſes upward to their ſpring.
Still with itſelf compar'd, his text peruſe;
Or let your comment be the Mantuan muſe.
† When firſt young Maro ſung of kings and wars,
Ere warning Phoebus touch'd his trembling ears,
Perhaps he ſeem'd above the critic's law,
And but from nature's fountains ſcorn'd to draw;
But when t'examine every part he came,
Nature and Homer were, he found, the ſame;
Convinc'd, amaz'd, he checks the bold deſign,
And rules as ſtrict his labour'd work confine,
As if the Stagyrite o'erlook'd each line.
[46] Learn hence for ancient rules a juſt eſteem,
To copy nature, is to copy them.
Some beauties yet, no precepts can declare,
For there's a happineſs as well as care.
Muſic reſembles poetry, in each
Are nameleſs graces which no methods teach,
And which a maſter-hand alone can reach.
† If where the rules not far enough extend,
(Since rules were made but to promote their end)
Some lucky licence anſwers to the full
Th' intent propos'd, that licence is a rule.
Thus Pegaſus a nearer way to take,
May boldly deviate from the common track.
Great wits ſometimes may gloriouſly offend,
And riſe to faults true criticks dare not mend;
From vulgar bounds with brave diſorder part,
And ſnatch a grace beyond the reach of art,
Which, without paſſing thro' the judgment, gains
The heart, and all its end at once attains
In proſpects thus ſome objects pleaſe our eyes,
Which out of nature's common order riſe,
The ſhapeleſs rock, or hanging precipice.
But care in poetry muſt ſtill be had,
It aſks diſcretion ev'n in running mad:
[48] And tho' the antients thus their rules invade,
(As kings diſpenſe with laws themſelves have made)
Moderns beware! or if you muſt offend
Againſt the precept, ne'er tranſgreſs its end.
Let it be ſeldom, and compell'd by need,
And have, at leaſt, their precedent to plead.
The critic elſe proceeds without remorſe,
Seizes your fame, and puts his laws in force.
I know there are, to whoſe preſumptuous thoughts
Thoſe freer beauties, even in them, ſeem faults.
Some figures monſtrous, and miſs-ſhap'd appear,
Conſider'd ſingly, or beheld too near,
Which, but proportion'd to their light, or place,
Due diſtance reconciles to form and grace.
A prudent chief not always muſt diſplay
His pow'rs in equal ranks, and fair array;
But with th' occaſion, and the place comply,
Conceal his force, nay, ſometimes ſeem to fly.
Thoſe oft are ſtratagems which errors ſeem,
Nor is it Homer nods, but we that dream.
Still green with bays each ancient altar ſtands,
Above the reach of ſacrilegious hands;
Secure from flames, from envy's fiercer rage,
Deſtructive war, and all-devouring age.
See, from each clime the learn'd their incenſe bring;
Hear in all tongues conſenting paeans ring!
[50] In praiſe ſo juſt let ev'ry voice be join'd,
And fill the general chorus of mankind!
Hail, bards triumphant! born in happier days,
Immortal heirs of univerſal praiſe!
Whoſe honours with increaſe of ages grow,
As ſtreams roll down enlarging as they flow!
Nations unborn your mighty names ſhall ſound,
And worlds applaud that muſt not yet be found!
Oh! may ſome ſpark of your celeſtial fire
The laſt, the meaneſt of your ſons inſpire,
(That on weak wings from far purſues your flights,
Glows while he reads, but trembles as he writes)
To teach vain wits a ſcience little known,
T'admire ſuperior ſenſe and doubt their own.
Of all the cauſes which conſpire to blind
Man's erring judgment, and miſguide the mind;
What the weak head with ſtrongeſt bias rules,
Is pride, the never-failing vice of fools.
Whatever nature has in worth deny'd,
She gives, in large recruits of needful pride;
For as in bodies, thus in ſouls we find,
What wants in blood and ſpirits, ſwell'd with wind:
Pride, where wit fails, ſteps in to our defence,
And fills up all the mighty void of ſenſe!
If once right reaſon drives that cloud away,
Truth breaks upon us with reſiſtleſs day;
[52] Truſt not yourſelf by your defects to know,
Make uſe of ev'ry friend—and ev'ry foe.
A little learning is a dang'rous thing,
Drink deep, or taſte not the Pierian ſpring;
There ſhallow draughts intoxicate the brain,
And drinking largely ſobers us again.
Fir'd at firſt ſight with what the muſe imparts,
In fearleſs youth we tempt the heights of arts,
While from the bounded level of our mind,
Short views we take, nor ſee the lengths behind;
But more advanc'd, behold with ſtrange ſurprize
New diſtant ſcenes of endleſs ſcience riſe!
So pleas'd at firſt the tow'ring Alps we try,
Mount o'er the vales, and ſeem to tread the ſky,
Th' eternal ſnows appear already paſt,
And the firſt clouds and mountains ſeem the laſt;
But thoſe attain'd, we tremble to ſurvey
The growing labour of the lengthen'd way,
Th' increaſing proſpect tires our wond'ring eyes,
Hills peep o'er hills, and Alps on Alps ariſe!
† A perfect judge will read each work of wit
With the ſame ſpirit that its author writ,
[54] Survey the whole, nor ſeek ſlight faults to find,
Where nature moves, and rapture warms the mind;
Nor loſe, for that malignant, dull delight,
The gen'rous pleaſure to be charm'd with wit:
But in ſuch lays as neither ebb nor flow,
Correctly cold, and regularly low,
That ſhunning faults, one quiet temper keep,
We cannot blame indeed—but we may ſleep▪
In wit, as nature, what affects our hearts
Is not th' exactneſs of peculiar parts:
'Tis not a lip, nor eye, we beauty call,
But the joint force, and full reſult of all.
Thus when we view ſome well-proportion'd dome,
(The world's juſt wonderd, and ev'n thine, O Rome!)
No ſingle parts unequally ſurprize,
All comes united to the admiring eyes;
No monſtrous height, or breadth, or length appear;
The whole at once is bold and regular.
Whoever thinks a faultleſs piece to ſee,
Thinks what ne'er was, nor is, nor e'er ſhall be.
In ev'ry work regard the writer's end,
Since none can compaſs more than they intend;
And if the means be juſt, the conduct true,
Applauſe, in ſpight of trivials faults, is due.
As men of breeding, ſometimes men of wit,
T'avoid great errors, muſt the leſs commit.
[56] Neglect the rules each verbal critic lays,
For not to know ſome trifles is a praiſe.
Moſt critics fond of ſome ſubſervient art,
Still make the whole depend upon a part,
They talk of principles, but notions prize,
And all to one lov'd folly ſacrifice.
Once, on a time, la Mancha's knight, they ſay,
A certain bard encount'ring on the way,
Diſcours'd in terms as juſt, in looks as ſage,
As e'er cou'd Dennis, of the Grecian ſtage;
Concluding all were deſp'rate ſots, and fools,
That durſt depart from Ariſtotle's rules.
Our author happy in a judge ſo nice,
Produc'd his play, and begg'd the knight's advice;
Made him obſerve the ſubject, and the plot,
The manners, paſſions, unities, what not?
All which, exact to rule, were brought about,
Were but a combat in the liſts left out
"What! leave the combat out?" exclaims the knight;
Yes, or we muſt renounce the Stagyrite.
"Not ſo, by heav'n! (he anſwers in a rage)
"Knights, ſquires, and ſteeds, muſt enter on the ſtage."
The ſtage can ne'er ſo vaſt a throng contain.
"Then build a-new, or act it on a plain."
Thus critics of leſs judgment than caprice,
Curious, not knowing, not exact, but nice,
[58] Form ſhort ideas, and offend in arts
(As moſt in manners) by a love to parts.
Some to conceit alone their taſte confine,
And glitt'ring thoughts ſtruck out at ev'ry line;
Pleas'd with a work, where nothing's juſt or fit,
One glaring chaos, and wild heap of wit.
Poets like painters, thus unſkill'd to trace
The naked nature, and the living grace,
With gold and jewels cover ev'ry part,
And hide with ornaments their want of art.
True
† wit is nature to advantage dreſs'd,
What oft was thought, but ne'er ſo well expreſs'd;
Something, whoſe truth convinc'd at ſight, we find,
That gives us back the image of our mind.
As ſhades more ſweetly recommend the light,
So modeſt plainneſs ſets off ſprightly wit:
For works may have more wit than does them good,
As bodies periſh through exceſs of blood.
Others, for language all their care expreſs,
And value books, as women men, for dreſs:
Their praiſe is ſtill—the ſtyle is excellent;
The ſenſe they humbly take upon content.
[60] Words are like leaves, and where they moſt abound,
Much fruit of ſenſe beneath is rarely found.
Falſe eloquence, like the priſmatic glaſs,
Its gaudy colours ſpreads on ev'ry place;
The face of nature we no more ſurvey,
All glares alike, without diſtinction gay;
But true expreſſion, like th' unchanging ſun;
Clears and improves whate'er it ſhines upon,
It gilds all objects but it alters none.
Expreſſion is the dreſs of thought, and ſtill
Appears more decent, as more ſuitable;
A vile conceit in pompous words expreſs'd,
Is like a clown in regal purple dreſs'd;
For diff'rent ſtyles with diff'rent ſubjects ſort,
As ſev'ral garbs, with country, town, and court.
Some
* by old words to fame have made pretence,
Ancients in phraſe, meer moderns in their ſenſe!
Such labour'd nothings in ſo ſtrange a ſtyle,
Amaze the unlearn'd, and make the learned ſmile.
Unlucky, as Fungoſo in the
† play;
Theſe ſparks with aukward vanity diſplay
What the fine gentleman wore yeſterday.
[62] And but ſo mimic ancient wits at beſt,
As apes our grandſires in their doublets dreſt.
In words, as faſhions, the ſame rule will hold;
Alike fantaſtic, if too new, or old;
Be not the firſt by whom the new are try'd,
Nor yet the laſt to lay the old aſide.
* But moſt by numbers judge a poet's ſong,
And ſmoth, or rough, with them, is right or wrong;
In the bright muſe tho' thouſand charms conſpire,
Her voice is all theſe tuneful fools admire;
Who haunt Parnaſſus but to pleaſe the ear,
Not mend their minds, as ſome to church repair,
Not for the doctrine, but the muſic there.
Theſe equal ſyllables alone require,
Tho'
† oft the ear the open vowels tire;
While expletives their feeble aid do join,
And ten low words oft creep in one dull line;
While they ring round the ſame unvary'd chimes,
With ſure returns of ſtill-expected rhymes.
Where'er you find, the cooling weſtern breeze,
In the next line, it whiſpers thro' the trees,
[64] If cryſtal ſtreams, with pleaſing murmurs creep,
The reader's threat'ned, not in vain, with ſleep.
Then at the laſt, and only couplet fraught
With ſome unmeaning thing they call a thought,
A needleſs Alexandrine ends the ſong,
That like a wounded ſnake, drags its ſlow length along.
Leave ſuch to tune their own dull rhymes, and know
What's roundly ſmooth, or languiſhingly ſlow,
And praiſe the eaſy vigour of a line
Where Denham's ſtrength, and Waller's ſweetneſs join.
True eaſe in writing comes from art not chance,
As thoſe move eaſieſt who have learn'd to dance.
'Tis not enough no harſhneſs gives offence,
The ſound muſt ſeem an echo to the ſenſe.
Soft is the ſtrain when Zephyr gently blows,
And the ſmooth ſtream in ſmoother numbers flows,
But when loud billows laſh the ſounding ſhore,
The hoarſe rough verſe ſhould like the torrent roar.
When Ajax ſtrives, ſome rock's vaſt weight to throw,
The line too labours, and the words move ſlow,
Not ſo, when ſwift Camilla ſcours the plain,
Flies o'er th' unbending corn, and ſkims along the main.
Hear how
* Timotheus various lays ſurprize,
And bid alternate paſſions fall and riſe!
[66] While at each change the ſon of Lybian Jove,
Now burns with glory, and then melts with love;
Now fierce his eyes with ſparkling fury glow!
Now ſighs ſteal out, and tears begin to flow;
Perſians and Greeks like turns of nature found,
And the world's victor ſtood ſubdu'd by ſound!
The pow'r of muſic all our hearts allow,
And what Timotheus was, is Dryden now.
Avoid extremes, and ſhun the fault of ſuch,
Who ſtill are pleas'd too little, or too much.
At ev'ry trifle ſcorn to take offence,
That always ſhows great pride, or little ſenſe.
Thoſe heads, as ſtomachs, are not ſure the beſt,
Which nauſeate all, and nothing can digeſt.
Yet let not each gay turn thy rapture move;
For fools admire, but men of ſenſe approve.
As things ſeem large which we thro' miſts deſcry,
Dulneſs is ever apt to magnify.
Some the French writers, ſome our own deſpiſe;
The ancients only, or the moderns prize.
(Thus wit, like faith, by each man is apply'd
To one ſmall ſect, and all are damn'd beſide,)
[68] Meanly they ſeek the bleſſing to confine,
And force that ſun but on a part to ſhine,
Which not alone the ſouthern wit ſublimes,
But ripens ſpirits in cold northern climes,
Which from the firſt has ſhone on ages paſt,
Enlights the preſent, and ſhall warm the laſt.
(Tho' each may feel increaſes and decays,
And ſee now clearer and now darker days)
Regard not then if wit be old or new,
But blame the falſe and value ſtill the true.
Some ne'er advance a judgment of their own,
But catch the ſpeading notion of the town;
They reaſon and conclude by precedent,
And own ſtale nonſenſe, which they ne'er invent.
Some judge of authors names, not works, and then
Nor praiſe, nor blame the writings, but the men.
Of all this ſervile herd, the worſt is he
Who in proud dulneſs joins with quality,
A conſtant critic at the great man's board,
To fetch and carry nonſenſe for my lord.
Wh [...]t woful ſtuff this madrigal wou'd be,
In ſome ſtarved hackney ſonneteer, or me?
But let a lord once own the happy lines,
How the wit brightens, how the ſtyle refines!
[70] Before his ſacred name flies ev'ry fault,
And each exalted ſtanza ſteems with thought!
The vulgar thus thro' imitation err,
As oft the learn'd by being ſingular;
So much they ſcorn the croud, that if the throng
By chance go right, they purpoſely go wrong:
So ſchiſmatics the plain believers quit,
And are but damn'd for having too much wit.
Some blame at morning what they praiſe at night;
But always think the laſt opinion right.
A muſe by theſe is like a miſtreſs us'd,
This hour ſhe's idoliz'd, the next abus'd;
While their weak heads like towns unfortify'd,
'Twixt ſenſe and nonſenſe daily change their ſide.
Aſk them the cauſe, they're wiſer ſtill they ſay;
And ſtill to-morrow's wiſer than to-day.
We think our fathers fools, ſo wiſe we grow;
Our wiſer ſons, no doubt, will think us ſo.
Once ſchool-divines this zealous iſle oe'erſpread;
Who knew moſt ſentences, was deepeſt read;
[72] Faith, goſpel, all, ſeem'd made to be diſputed,
And none had ſenſe enough to be confuted:
Scotiſts and Thomiſts, now in peace remain,
Amidſt their kindred cobwebs in Duck-lane.
If faith itſelf has diff'rent dreſſes worn,
What wonder modes in wit ſhou'd take their turn?
Oft leaving what is natural and fit,
The current folly proves the ready wit;
And authors think their reputation ſafe,
Which lives as long as fools are pleas'd to laugh.
Some valuing thoſe of their own ſide or mind,
Still make themſelves the meaſure of mankind;
Fondly we think we honour merit then,
When we but praiſe ourſelves in other men.
Parties in wit attend on thoſe of ſtate,
And public faction doubles private hate.
Pride, malice, folly, againſt Dryden roſe,
In various ſhapes of parſons, critics, beaus;
But ſenſe ſurviv'd when merry jeſts were paſt;
For riſing merit will buoy up at laſt.
Might he return and bleſs once more our eyes,
New Blackmores and new Milbournes muſt ariſe;
Nay, ſhou'd great Homer lift his awful head,
Zoilus again wou'd ſtart up from the dead.
[74] Envy will merit, as its ſhade purſue,
But like a ſhadow proves the ſubſtance true;
For envy'd wit, like Sol eclips'd, makes known
Th' oppoſing body's groſſneſs, not its own.
When firſt the ſun too pow'rful beams diſplays,
It draws up vapours which obſcure the rays;
But ev'n thoſe clouds at laſt adorn its way,
Reflect new glories and augment the day.
Be thou the firſt true merit to befriend,
His praiſe is loſt who ſtays till all commend.
Short is the date, alas! of modern rhymes,
And 'tis but juſt to let them live betimes.
No longer now that golden age appears,
When patriarch-wits ſurviv'd a thouſand years;
Now length of fame (our ſecond life) is loſt,
And bare threeſcore, is all ev'n that can boaſt;
Our ſons their fathers failing language ſee,
And ſuch as Chaucer is, ſhall Dryden be.
So when the faithful pencil has deſign'd
Some bright idea of the maſter's mind,
Where a new world leaps out at his command,
And ready nature waits upon his hand;
[76] When the ripe colours ſoften and unite,
And ſweetly melt into juſt ſhade and light,
When mellowing years their full perfection give,
And each bold figure juſt begins to live,
The treach'rous colours the fair art betray,
And all the bright creation fades away.
Unhappy wit, like moſt miſtaken things,
Attones not for the envy which it brings.
In youth alone its empty praiſe we boaſt,
But ſoon the ſhort-liv'd vanity is loſt!
Like ſome fair flow'r the early ſpring ſupplies,
That gaily blooms, but ev'n in blooming dies.
What is this wit which moſt our cares employ?
The owner's wife, that other men enjoy;
Still moſt our trouble, when the moſt admir'd;
The more we give, the more is ſtill requir'd:
The fame with pains we gain, but loſe with eaſe,
Sure ſome to vex, but never all to pleaſe;
'Tis what the vicious fear; the virtuous ſhun,
By fools 'tis hated, and by knaves undone!
[78]If wit ſo much from ign'rance undergo,
Ah, let not learning too commence its foe!
Of old, thoſe met rewards who cou'd excel,
And ſuch were prais'd, who but endeavour'd well;
Tho' triumphs were to gen'rals only due,
Crowns were reſerv'd to grace the ſoldier too.
Now they who reach Parnaſſus lofty crown,
Employ their pains to ſpurn ſome others down;
And while ſelf-love each jealous writer rules,
Contending wits become the ſport of fools.
But ſtill the worſt with moſt regret commend,
For each ill author is as bad a friend.
To what baſe end, and by what abject ways,
Are mortals urg'd thro' ſacred luſt of praiſe!
Ah, ne'er ſo dire a thirſt of glory boaſt,
Nor in the critic let the man be loſt:
Good-nature, and good-ſenſe muſt ever join;
To err is human, to forgive divine.
But if in noble minds ſome dregs remain,
Not yet purg'd off, of ſpleen and ſour diſdain;
Diſcharge that rage on more provoking crimes,
Nor fear a dearth in theſe flagitious times.
No pardon vile obſcenity ſhou'd find,
Tho' wit and art conſpire to move your mind:
[80] But dulneſs with obſcenity muſt prove,
As ſhameful ſure as impotence in love.
In the fat age of pleaſure, wealth and eaſe,
Sprung the rank weed, and thriv'd with large increaſe;
When love was all an eaſy monarch's care,
Seldom at a council, never in a war:
Jilts rul'd the ſtate, and ſtateſmen farces writ;
Nay wits had penſions, and young lords had wit:
The fair ſate panting at a courtier's play,
And not a maſk went unimprov'd away:
The modeſt fan was lifted up no more,
And virgins ſmil'd at what they bluſh'd before—
The following licence of a foreign reign
Did all the dregs of bold Socinus drain;
Then unbelieving prieſts reform'd the nation,
And taught more pleaſant methods of ſalvation;
Where heaven's free ſubjects might their rights diſpute,
Leſt God himſelf ſhould ſeem too abſolute.
Pulpits their ſacred ſatire learn'd to ſpare,
And vice admir'd to find a flatt'rer there!
Encourag'd thus, wit's Titans brav'd the ſkies,
And the preſs groan'd with licenc'd blaſphemies—
[82] Theſe monſters, critics, with your darts engage,
Here point your thunder, and exhauſt your rage!
Yet ſhun their fault, who ſcandalouſly nice,
Will needs miſtake an author into vice;
All ſeems infected that th' infected ſpy,
As all looks yellow to the jaundic'd eye.
Learn then what morals critics ought to ſhow,
For 'tis but half a judge's taſk to know.
'Tis not enough wit, art, and learning join;
In all you ſpeak, let truth and candour ſhine:
That not alone what to your judgment's due
All may allow; but ſeek your friendſhip too.
Be ſilent always when you doubt your ſenſe;
And ſpeak, tho' ſure, with ſeeming diffidence;
Some poſitive, perſiſting fops we know,
That if once wrong, will needs be always ſo;
But you with pleaſure own your errors paſt,
And make each day, a critic on the laſt.
'Tis not enough your counſel ſtill be true,
Blunt truths more miſchief than nice falſhoods do;
Men muſt be taught as if you taught 'em not,
And things unknown propos'd as things forgot.
[84] Without good-breeding, truth is diſapprov'd;
That only makes ſuperior ſenſe belov'd.
Be niggards of advice on no pretence;
For the worſt avarice is that of ſenſe.
With mean complacence ne'er betray your truſt,
Nor be ſo civil as to prove unjuſt;
Fear moſt the anger of the wiſe to raiſe,
Thoſe beſt can bear reproof who merit praiſe.
'Twere well, might critics ſtill this freedom take,
But Appius reddens at each word you ſpeak,
And ſtares, tremendous with a threat'ning eye,
Like ſome fierce tyrant in old tapeſtry!
Fear moſt to tax an honourable fool,
Whoſe right it is uncenſur'd to be dull;
Such without wit are poets when they pleaſe,
As without learning they can take degrees.
Leave dang'rous truths to unſucceſsful ſatyrs,
And flattery to fulſome dedicators,
Whom, when they praiſe, the world believes no more,
Than when they promiſe to give ſcribbling o'er.
'Tis beſt ſometimes your cenſure to reſtrain
And charitably let the dull be vain.
[86] Your ſilence there is better than your ſpite,
For who can rail ſo long as they can write?
Still humming on their drowſy courſe they keep,
And laſh'd ſo long, like tops, are laſh'd aſleep.
Falſe ſteps but help them to renew the race,
As after ſtumbling, jades will mend their pace:
What crouds of theſe, impertinently bold,
In ſounds, and jing'ling ſyllables grown old,
Still run on poets in a raging vein,
Ev'n to the dregs, and ſqueezings of the brain:
Strain out the laſt dull droppings of their ſenſe,
And rhyme with all the rage of impotence.
Such ſhameleſs bards we have, and yet 'tis true,
There are as mad abandon'd critics too.
The book-full blockhead, ignorantly read,
With loads of learned lumber in his head,
With his own tongue, ſtill edifies his ears,
And always liſtning to himſelf appears—
All books he reads, and all he reads aſſails
From Dryden's fables, down to Durfy's tales.
With him moſt authors ſteal their works, or buy;
Garth did not write his own diſpenſary.
Name a new play, and he's the poet's friend,
Nay, ſhow'd his faults—but when wou'd poets mend?
[88] No place ſo ſacred from ſuch fops is barr'd,
Nor is Paul's-church more ſafe than Paul's-church-yard;
Nay fly to altars; there he'll talk you dead;
For fools ruſh in where angels fear to tread.
Diſtruſtful ſenſe with modeſt caution ſpeaks,
It ſtill looks home, and ſhort excurſions makes,
But rattling nonſenſe in full vollies breaks,
And never ſhock'd, and never turn'd aſide,
Burſts out, reſiſtleſs, with a thund'ring tide!
But where's the man, who counſel can beſtow,
Still pleas'd to teach, and yet not proud to know?
Unbias'd, or by favour, or by ſpite;
Not dully prepoſſeſs'd, or blindly right,
Tho' learn'd, well-bred; and tho' well-bred, ſincere,
Modeſtly bold, and humanely ſevere?
Who to a friend his faults can freely ſhow,
And gladly praiſe the merit of a foe?
Bleſt with a taſte exact and unconfin'd;
A knowledge both of books and human kind;
Gen'rous converſe; a ſoul exempt from pride,
And love to praiſe, with reaſon on his ſide?
Such once were critics; ſuch the happy few,
Athens and Rome in better ages knew.
The mighty Stagyrite firſt left the ſhore,
Spread all his ſails, and durſt the deep explore;
[90] He ſteer'd ſecurely, and diſcover'd far,
Led by the light of the Maeonian ſtar.
Poets, a race long unconfin'd and free,
Still fond and proud of ſavage liberty,
Receiv'd his laws, and ſtood convinc'd 'twas fit,
Who conquer'd nature, ſhould preſide o'er wit.
Horace ſtill charms with graceful negligence,
And without method talks us into ſenſe,
Will like a friend, familiarly convey
The trueſt notions in the eaſieſt way;
He, who ſupreme in judgment, as in wit,
Might boldly cenſure, as he boldly writ;
Yet judg'd with coolneſs, tho' he ſung with fire,
His precepts teach but what his works inſpire.
Our critics take a contrary extreme
They judge with fury, but they write with phlegm;
Nor ſuffers Horace more in wrong tranſlations
By wits, than critics in as wrong quotations.
See Dionyſius
* Homer's thoughts refine,
And call new beauties forth from ev'ry line.
Fancy and art in gay Petronius pleaſe,
The ſcholar's learning, with the courtier's eaſe.
In grave Quintilian's copious work we find
The juſteſt rules, and cleareſt method join'd;
[92] Thus uſeful arms in magazines we place,
All rang'd in order, and diſpos'd with grace.
Nor thus alone the curious eye to pleaſe,
But to be found when need requires with eaſe.
Thee, bold Longinus! all the Nine inſpire,
And bleſs their critic with a poet's fire;
An ardent judge, who zealous in his truſt
With warmth gives ſentence, yet is always juſt;
Whoſe own example ſtrengthens all his laws,
And is himſelf that great ſublime he draws.
Thus long ſucceeding critics juſtly reign'd
Licence repreſs'd, and uſeful laws ordain'd.
Learning and Rome alike in empire grew,
And arts ſtill follow'd where her eagles flew;
From the ſame foes, at laſt, both felt their doom,
And the ſame age ſaw learning fall and Rome.
With tyranny, then ſuperſtition join'd,
As that the body, this enſlav'd the mind;
Much was believ'd, but little underſtood,
And to be dull was conſtru'd to be good;
A ſecond deluge learning thus o'er-run,
And the Monks finiſh'd what the Goths begun.
At length Eraſmus, that great injur'd name,
(The glory of the prieſt-hood, and the ſhame)
[94] Stemn'd the wild torrent of a barb'rous age,
And drove thoſe holy Vandals off the ſtage.
But ſee each muſe in Leo's golden days,
Starts from her trance, and trims her wither'd bays!
Rome's ancient genius, o'er its ruins ſpread,
Shakes off the duſt, and rears his rev'rend head!
Then Sculpture and her ſiſter arts revive,
Stones leap'd to form, and rocks began to live;
With ſweeter notes each riſing temple rung;
A Raphael painted, and a
* Vida ſung!
Immortal Vida! on whoſe honour'd brow
The poets bays, and critics ivy grow:
Cremona now ſhall ever boaſt thy name,
As next in place to Mantua, next in fame!
But ſoon by impious arms from Latium chac'd,
Their ancient bounds the baniſh'd muſes paſt;
Thence arts o'er all the northern world advance;
But critic learning flouriſh'd moſt in France:
The rules, a nation born to ſerve obeys;
And Boileau ſtill in right of Horace ſways;
But we, brave Britons, foreign laws deſpis'd,
And kept unconquer'd, and unciviliz'd,
[96] Fierce for the liberties of wit, and bold,
We ſtill deſy'd the Romans, as of old.
Yet ſome there were among the founder few
Of thoſe who leſs preſum'd, and better knew,
Who durſt aſſert the juſter ancient cauſe,
And here reſtor'd wit's fundamental laws.
Such was the muſe, whoſe rules and practice tell,
Nature's
* chief maſter-piece is writing well.
Such was Roſcommon—not more learn'd than good,
With manners gen'rous as his noble blood;
To him the wit of Greece and Rome was known,
And ev'ry author's merit but his own.
Such late was Walſh—the muſe's judge and friend;
Who juſtly knew to blame, or to commend;
To failings mild, but zealous for deſert;
The cleareſt head, and the ſincereſt heart.
This humble praiſe, lamented ſhade! receive,
This praiſe at leaſt a grateful muſe may give!
The muſe, whoſe early voice you taught to ſing,
Preſcrib'd her heights, and prun'd her tender wing;
(Her guide now loſt) no more pretends to riſe,
But in low numbers ſhort excurſions tries;
Content, if hence th' unlearn'd their wants may view,
The learn'd reflect on what before they knew:
[98] Careleſs of cenſure, nor too fond of fame,
Still pleas'd to praiſe, yet not afraid to blame:
Averſe alike to flatter or offend,
Not free from faults, nor yet too vain to mend.
DE ARTE CRITICA.
[35]DICTU difficile eſt, an ſit dementia major
Egiſſe invitâ vatem criticumne Minervâ;
Ille tamen certe venia tibi dignior errat
Qui laſſat, quam qui ſeducit in avia, ſenſus.
Sunt, qui abſurda canunt; ſed enim ſtultiſſima ſtultos
Quam longe exuperat oriticorum natio vates;
Se ſolum exhibuit quondam, melioribus annis
Natus hebes, ridendum; at nunc muſa improba prolem
Innumeram gignit, quae mox ſermone ſoluto
Aequiparet ſtolidos verſus, certetque ſtupendo.
Nobis judicium, veluti quae dividit horas
Machina, conſtruitur, motus non omnibus idem,
Non pretium, regit uſque tamen ſua quemque. Poetas
Divite perpaucos venâ donavit Apollo,
Et criticis recte ſapere eſt rariſſima virtus;
Arte in utraque nitent felices indole ſoli,
Muſaque quos placido naſcentes lumine vidit.
Ille alios melius, qui inclaruit ipſe, docebit,
Jureque quam meruit, poterit tribuiſſe coronam.
[37] Scriptores (fateor) fidunt propriae nimis arti,
Nonne autem criticos pravus favor urget ibidem?
At vero propius ſi ſtemus, cuique fatendum eſt,
Judicium quoddam natura inſeverit olim:
Illa diem certe dubiam diffundere callet
Et, ſtrictim deſcripta licet, ſibi linea conſtat.
Sed minimum ut ſpecimen, quod pictor doctus adumbrat,
Deterius tibi fiat eo mage, quo mage vilem
Inducas iſti fucum, ſic mentis honeſtae
Doctrina effigiem maculabit prava decoram.
His inter caecas mens illaqueata ſcholarum
Ambages errat, ſtolidiſque ſupervenit illis
(Diis aliter viſum eſt) petulantia. Perdere ſenſum
Communem hi ſudant, dum fruſtra aſcendere Pindum
Conantur, mox, ut ſe defenſoribus ipſis
Utantur, critici quoque fiunt: omnibus idem
Ardor ſcribendi, ſtudio hi rivalis aguntur,
Illis invalida Eunuchi violentia gliſcit.
Ridendi proprium eſt fatuis cacoethes, amantque
Turbae perpetuo ſeſe immiſcere jocoſae.
Maevius invito dum ſudat Apolline, multi
Pingue opus exuperant (ſi diis placet) emendando.
Sunt qui belli homines primo, tum deinde poetae,
Mox critici evaſêre, meri tum denique ſtulti.
Eſt, qui nec criticum nec vatem reddit, inerſque
Ut mulus, medium quoddam eſt aſinum inter equmuque.
[39] Bellula ſemihominum vix poene elementa ſcientum
Primula gens horum eſt, premitur quibus Anglia, quantum
Imperfecta ſcatent ripis animalcula Nili,
Futile, abortivum genus, & prope nominis expers,
Uſque adeo aequivoca eſt, e quâ generantur, origo.
Hos centum nequeunt linguae numerare, nec una
Unius ex ipſis, quae centum ſola fatiget.
At tu qui famam ſimul exigis atque redonas
Pro meritis, criticique affectas nobile nomen.
Metitor te ipſum, prudenſque expendito quae ſit
Judicii, ingenii tibi, doctrinaeque facultas;
Si qua profunda nimis cauto vitentor, & iſta
Linea, quâ coeunt ſtupor ingeniumque, notator.
Qui finem impoſuit rebus Deus omnibus aptum,
Humani vanum ingenii reſtrinxit acumen.
Qualis ubi oceani vis noſtra irrumpit in arva
Tunc deſolatas alibi denudat arenas;
Sic animae reminiſcendi dum copia reſtat,
Conſilii gravioris abeſt plerumque poteſtas;
Aſt ubi Phantaſiae fulgent radiantia tela,
Mnemoſyne teneris cum formis victa liqueſcit.
Ingenio tantum Muſa uni ſufficit una,
Tanta ars eſt, tantilla ſcientia noſtra videtur:
Non ſolum ad certas artes aſtricta ſequendas,
Saepe has non niſi quâdam in ſimplice parte ſequatur.
Deperdas partos utcunque labore triumphos,
Dum plures, regum inſtar, aves acquirere laurus;
[41] Sed ſua tractatu facilis provincia cuique eſt,
Si non, quae pulchre ſciat, ut vulgaria, temnat.
Naturam ſequere imprimis, atque illius aequâ
Judicium ex normâ fingas, quae neſcia flecti:
Illa etenim, ſine labe micans, ab origine divâ,
Clarâ, conſtanti, luſtrantique omnia luce,
Vitamque, ſpecimque, & vires omnibus addat,
Et fons, & finis ſimul, atque criterion artis.
Quaerit opes ex hoc theſauro ars, & ſine pompâ
Praeſidet, & nullas turbas facit inter agendum.
Talis vivida vis formoſo in corpore mentis,
Laetitiam toti inſpirans & robora maſſae,
Ordinat & motus, & nervos ſuſtinet omnes,
Inter opus varium tamen ipſa abſcondita fallit.
Saepe is, cui magnum ingenium Deus addidit, idem
Indigus eſt majoris, ut hoc benè calleat uti;
Ingenium nam judicio velut uxor habendum eſt
Atque viro, cui fas ut pareat, uſque repugnat.
Muſae quadrupedem labor eſt inhibere capiſtro,
Praecipites regere, at non irritare volatus.
Pegaſos, inſtar equi generoſi, grandior ardet
Cum ſentit retinacula, nobiliorque tuetur.
Regula quaeque vetus tantum obſervata peritis
Non inventa fuit criticis, debetque profectò
Naturae aſcribi, ſed enim quam lima polivit;
[43] Nullas naturae divina monarchia leges,
Exceptis ſolum quas ſanxerit ipſa, veretur.
Qualibus, audiſtin' reſonat celeberrima normis
Graecia, ſeu doctum premit, indulgetve furorem?
Illa ſuos ſiſtit Parnaſſi in vertice natos,
Et, quibus aſcendêre docet, ſalebroſa viarum,
Sublimique manu dona immortalia monſtrat,
Atque aequis reliquos procedere paſſibus urget.
Sic magnis doctrinâ ex exemplaribus hauſtâ,
Sumit ab hiſce, quod haec duxerunt ab Jove ſummo.
Ingenuus judex muſarum ventilat ignes,
Et fretus ratione docet praecepta placendi.
Ars critica officioſa Camoenae ſervit, & ornat
Egregias veneres, plureſque irretit amantes.
Nunc vero docti longè diverſa ſequentes,
Contempti dominae, vilem petiêre miniſtram;
Propriaque in miſeros verterunt tela poetas,
Diſcipulique ſuos pro more odêre magiſtros.
Haud aliter ſanè noſtrates pharmacopolae
Ex medicûm crevit quibus ars plagiaria chartis,
Audaces errorum adhibent ſine mente medelas,
Et verae Hippocratis jactant convicia proli.
Hi veterum authorum ſcriptis veſcuntur, & ipſos
Vermiculos, & tempus edax vicêre vorando.
[45] Stultitiâ ſimplex ille, & ſine divite venà,
Carmina quo fiant pacto miſerabilè narrat.
Doctrinam oſtentans, mentem alter perdidit omnem,
Atque alter nodis vafer implicat enodando.
Tu quicunque cupis judex procedere rectè,
Fac veteris cujuſque ſtylus diſcatur ad unguem;
Fabula, materies, quo tendat pagina quaevis;
Patria, religio quae ſint, queis moribus aevum:
Si non intuitu cuncta haec complecteris uno,
Scurra, cavilator—criticus mihi non eris unquam.
Ilias eſto tibi ſtudium, tibi ſola voluptas,
Perque diem lege, per noctes meditare ſerenas;
Hinc tibi judicium, hinc ortum ſententia ducat,
Muſarumque undas ſontem bibe laetus ad ipſum.
Ipſe ſuorum operum ſit commentator, & author,
Maeonidiſve legas interprete ſcripta Marone.
Cum caneret primum parvus Maro bella viroſque,
Nec monitor Phoebus tremulas jam velleret aures,
Legibus immunem criticis ſe fortè putabat,
Nil niſi naturam archetypam dignatus adire:
Sed ſimul ac cautè mentem per ſingula volvit,
Naturam invenit, quacunque invenit Homerum.
Victus, & attonitus, maleſani deſinit auſi,
Jamque laboratum in numerum vigil omnia cogit,
Cultaque Ariſtotelis metitur carmina normâ.
[47] Hinc veterum diſcas praecepta vererier, illos
Sectator, ſic naturam ſectaberis ipſam.
At vero virtus reſtat jam plurima, nullo
Deſcribenda modo, nullâque parabilis arte,
Nam felix tam fortuna eſt, quam cura canendi.
Muſicam in hoc reddit divina poeſis, utramque
Multae ornant veneres, quas verbis pingere non eſt,
Quaſque attingere nil niſi ſumma peritia poſſit.
Regula quandocunque minus diffuſa videtur
(Quum tantum ad propriam collinet ſingula metam)
Si modo conſiliis inſerviat ulla juvandis
Apta licentia, lex enim iſta licentia fiat.
Atque ita quo cituis procedat, calle relicto
Communi muſae ſonipes benè devius erret.
Accidit interdum, ut ſcriptores ingenium ingens
Evehat ad culpam egregiam, maculaſque micantes
Quas nemo criticorum audet detergere figat;
Accidit ut linquat vulgaria clauſtra furore
Magnanimo, rapiatque ſolutum lege dccorem,
Qui, quum judicium non intercedat, ad ipſum
Cor properat, fineſque illic ſimul obtinet omnes.
Haud aliter ſi forte jugo ſpeculamur aprico,
Luminibus res arrident, quas Daedala tellus
Parcior oſtentare ſolet, velut ardua montis
Aſperitas, ſcopulive exeſi pendulus horror.
Cura tamen ſemper magna eſt adhibenda poeſi,
Atque hic cum ratione inſaniat author, oportet:
[49] Et, quamvis veteres pro tempore jura refigunt,
Et leges violare ſuas regalitèr audent,
Tu caveas, moneo, quiſquis nunc ſcribis, & ipſam
Si legem frangas, memor ejus reſpice finem.
Hoc ſemper tamen evites, niſi te gravis urget
Nodus, praemonſtrantque authorum exempla priorum.
Ni facias, criticus totam implacabilis iram
Exercet, turpique notâ tibi nomen inurit.
Sed non me latuêre, quibus ſua liberiores
Has veterum veneres vitio dementia vertit.
Et quaedam tibi ſigna quidem monſtroſa videntur,
Si per ſe vel perpendas, propiorave luſtres,
Quae rectâ cum conſtituas in luce locoque,
Formam conciliat diſtantia juſta venuſtam.
Non aciem ſemper belli dux callidus artis
Inſtruit aequali ſerie ordinibuſque decoris,
Sed ſe temporibuſque locoque accomodat, agmen
Celando jam, jamque fugae ſimulachra ciendo.
Mentitur ſpeciem erroris ſaepe aſtus, & ipſe
Somniat emunctus judex, non dormit Homerus.
Aſpice, laurus adhuc antiquis vernat in aris,
Quas rabidae violare manus non amplius audent;
Flammarum a rabie tutas, Stygiaeque veneno
Invidiae, Martiſque minis & morſibus aevi.
Docta caterva, viden! fert ut fragrantia thura;
Audin ut omnigenis reſonant praeconia linguis!
[51] Laudes uſque adeo meritas vox quaeque rependat,
Humanique ſimul generis chorus omnis adeſto.
Salvete, O vates! nati melioribus annis,
Munus & immortale aeternae laudis adepti!
Queis juveneſcit honos longo maturior aevo,
Ditior ut diffundit aquas, dum defluit amnis!
Vos populi mundique canent, ſacra nomina, quos jam
Inventrix (ſic diis viſum eſt) non contigit aetas!
Pars aliqua, o utinam! ſacro ſcintillet ab igne
Illi, qui veſtra eſt extrema & humillima proles!
(Qui longe ſequitur vos debilioribus alis
Lector magnanimus, ſed enim, ſed ſcriptor inaudax)
Sic critici vani, me praecipiente, priores
Mirari, arbitrioque ſuo diffidere diſcant.
Omnibus ex cauſis, quae animum corrumpere junctis
Viribus, humanumque ſolent obtundere acumen,
Pingue caput ſolita eſt momento impellere ſummo
Stultitiae ſemper cognata ſuperbia; quantum
Mentis naſcenti fata invidere, profuſo
Tantum ſubſidio faſtûs ſuperaddere gaudent;
Nam veluti in membris, ſic ſaepe animabus, inanes
Exundant vice
† ſpirituum, vice ſanguinis aurae
Suppetias inopi venit alma ſuperbia menti,
Atque per immenſum capitis ſe extendit inane!
Quod ſi recta valet ratio hanc diſpergere nubem
Naturae verique dies ſincera refulget.
[53] Cuicunque eſt animus penitus cognoſcere culpas,
Nec ſibi, nec ſociis credat, verum omnibus aurem
Commodet, apponatque inimica opprobria lucro.
Ne muſae invigiles mediocritèr, aut fuge fontem
Caſtalium omnino, aut hauſtu te prolue pleno:
Iſtius laticis tibi mens abſtemia torpet
Ebria, ſobrietaſque redit revocata bibendo.
Intuitu muſae primo, novitateque capta
Aſpirat doctrinae ad culmina ſumma juventus
Intrepida, & quoniam tunc mens eſt arcta, ſuoque
Omnia metitur modulo, malè lippa labores
Ponè ſecuturos oculis non aſpicit aequis:
Mox autem attonitae jam jamque ſcientia menti
Crebreſcit variata modis ſine limite miris!
Sic ubi deſertis conſcendere vallibus Alpes
Aggredimur, nubeſque humiles calcare videmur,
Protinus aeternas ſuperâſſe nives, & in ipſo
Inveniſſe viae laetamur limine finem:
His vero exactis tacito terrore ſtupemus
Durum creſcentem magis & magis uſque laborem,
Jam longus tandem proſpectus laeſa fatigat
Lumina, dum colles aſſurgunt undique faeti
Collibus, impoſitaeque emergunt Alpibus Alpes.
Ingenioſa leget judex perfectus eâdem
Quâ vates ſcripſit ſtudioſus opuſcula curâ,
[55] Totum perpendet, cenſorque eſt parcus, ubi ardor
Exagitat naturae animos & concitat oeſtrum;
Nec tam ſervili generoſa libidine mutet
Gaudia, quae bibulae menti catus ingerit author.
Verum ſtagnantis mediocria carmina muſae,
Quae reptant ſub limâ & certâ lege ſtupeſcunt,
Quae torpent uno erroris ſecura tenore,
Haec equidem nequeo culpare—& dormio tantum.
Ingenii, veluti naturae, non tibi conſtant
Illecebrae formâ, quae certis partibus inſit;
Nam te non reddit labiumve oculuſve venuſtum,
Sed charitum cumulus, collectaque tela decoris.
Sic ubi luſtramus perfectam inſignitèr aedem,
(Quae Roman ſplendore, ipſumqne ita perculit orbem)
Laeta diu non ullâ in ſimplice parte morantur
Lumina, ſed ſeſe per totum errantia paſcunt;
Nil longum latumve nimis, nil altius aequo
Cernitur, illuſtris nitor omnibus, omnibus ordo.
Quod conſummatum eſt opus omni ex parte, nec uſquam
Nunc exſtat, nec erat, nec erit labentibus annis.
Quas ſibi proponat metas adverte, poeta
Ultra aliquid ſperare, illas ſi abſolvat, iniquum eſt;
Si recta ratione utatur, conſilioque
Perfecto, miſſis maculis, vos plaudite clamo.
Accidit, ut vates, veluti vafer Aulicus, erret
Soepius errorem, ut vitet graviora, minorem.
[57] Neglige, quas criticus, verborum futilis auceps,
Leges edicit: nugas neſcire decorum eſt.
Artis cujuſdam tantum auxiliaris amantes
Partem aliquam plerique colunt vice totius; illi
Multa crepant de judicio, nihilominus iſtam
Stultitiam, ſua quam ſententia laudat, adorant.
QUIXOTUS quondam, ſi vera eſt fabula, cuidam
Occurrens vati, criticum certamen inivit
Docta citans, graviterque tuens, tanquam arbiter alter
DENNISIUS, Graii moderatus fraena theatri;
Acriter id dein aſſeruit, ſtultum eſſe hebetemque,
Quiſquis Ariſtotelis poſſet contemnere leges.
Quid?—talem comitem nactus felicitèr author,
Mox tragicum, quod compoſuit, proferre poema
Incipit, et critici ſcitari oracula tanti.
Jam [...] que &
Caetera de genere hoc equiti deſcribat hianti,
Quae cuncta ad norman quadrarent, inter agendum
Si tantum prudens certamen omitteret author.
"Quid vero certamen omittes? excipit heros;
Sic veneranda Sophi ſuadent documenta. "Quid ergo,
Armigerumque equitum que cohors ſcenam intret, oportet,"
Forſan, at ipſa capax non tantae ſcena catervae eſt:
"OEdificave aliam—vel apertis utere campis."
Sic ubi ſuppoſito moroſa ſuperbia regnat
Judicio, criticaeque tenent faſtidia curae
[59] Vana locum, curto modulo aeſtimat omnia cenſor,
Atque modo perverſus in artibus errat eodem,
Moribus ac multi, dum parte laborat in unâ.
Sunt, qui nil ſapiant, ſalibus niſi quaeque redundet
Pagina, perpetuoque nitet diſtincta lepore,
Nil aptum ſoliti juſtumve requirere, latè
Si micet ingenii chaos, indiſcretaque moles.
Nudas naturae veneres, vivumque decorem
Fingere, qui nequeunt, quorundam exempla ſecuti
Pictorum, haud gemmis parcunt, haud ſumptibus auri,
Ut ſeſe abſcondat rutilis inſcitia velis.
Vis veri ingenii, natura eſt cultior, id quod
Senſerunt multi, ſed jam ſcite exprimit unus,
Quod primo pulchrum intuitu, rectumque videtur
Et mentis menti ſimulachra repercutit ipſi.
Haud ſecus ac lucem commendant ſuavitur umbrae,
Ingenio ſic ſimplicitas ſuperaddit honorem:
Nam fieri poſſit muſa ingenioſior aequo,
Et pereant tumidae nimio tibi ſanguine venae.
Nonnulli vero verborum in cortice ludunt,
Ornatuſque libri ſolos muliebriter ardent.
Egregium ecce! ſtylum clamant! ſed ſemper ocellis
Praetereunt malé, ſi quid ineſt rationis, inunctis.
[61] Verba, velut frondes, nimio cum tegmine opacant
Ramos, torpeſcunt mentis ſine germine. Prava
Rhetorice, vitri latè radian [...]is ad inſtar
Priſmatici, rutilos diffundit ubique colores;
Non tibi naturae licet amplius ora tueri,
At malè diſcretis ſcintillant omnia flammis:
Sed contra veluti jubar immutabile ſolis,
Quicquid contrectat facundia, luſtrat et auget,
Nil variat, ſed cuncta oculo ſplendoris inaurat.
Elòquium mentis noſtrae quaſi veſtis habenda eſt,
Quae ſi ſit ſatis apta, decentior inde videtur
Scommata magnificis ornata procacia verbis
Indutos referunt regalia ſyrmata faunos;
Diverſis etenim diverſa vocabula rebus
Appi gi fas eſt, aulae velut aulica veſtis,
Alteraque agricolis, atque altera congruit urbi.
Quidam ſcriptores, antiquis vocibus uſi,
Gloriolam affectant, veterum aemula turba ſonorum,
Si mentem ſpectes juvenentur more recentûm.
Tantula nugamenta ſtyloque operoſa vetuſto,
Docti derident ſoli placitura popello.
Hi nihilo magè felices quam comicus iſte
FUNGOSO, oſtentant abſurdo pepla tumore,
Qualia neſcio quis geſtavit nobilis olim;
[63] Atque modo veteres doctos imitantur eodem,
Ac hominem veteri in tunicâ dum ſimia ludit.
Verba, velut mores, a juſtis legibus errant,
Si nimium antiquae ſuerint, nimiumve novatae;
Tu cave ne ten [...]es inſueta vocabula primus,
Nec vetera abjicias poſtremus nomina rerum.
Laevis an aſper eat verſus plerique requirunt
Cenſores, ſoloſque ſonos damnantve probantve;
Mille licet veneres formoſam Pierin ornent,
Stultitiâ vox argutâ celabrabitur una:
Qui juga Parnaſſi non ut mala corda repurgent,
Auribus ut placeant, viſunt: ſic ſaepe profanos
Impulit ad reſonum pietas aurita ſacellum.
His ſolum criticis ſemper par ſyllaba cordi eſt,
Vaſtâ etſi uſque omnis pateat vocalis hiatu;
Expletivaque ſaepe ſuas quoque ſuppetias dent,
Ac verſum unum oneret levium heu! decas en! pigra vocum;
Dum non mutato reſonant malé cymbala planctu,
Atque augur miſer uſque ſcio, quid deinde ſequatur.
Quacunque aſpirat clementior aura Favonî,
Mox (nullus dubito) graciles vibrantur ariſtae
[65] Rivulus ut molli ſerpit per laevia lapſu,
Lector, non temerè expectes, poſt murmura, ſomnos.
Tum demum qua latè extremum ad diſtichon, ipſa
Magnificum ſine mente nihil, SENTENTIA ſplendet,
Segnis Hypermeter, audin? adeſt, et claudicat, inſtar
Anguis ſaucia terga trahentis, prorepentiſque.
Hiproprias ſtupeant nugas, tu diſcere tentes,
Quae tereti properant venâ, vel amabilè languent.
Iſtaque fac laudes, ubi vivida Denhamii vis
Walleriae condita fluit dulcedine muſae.
Scribendi numeroſa facultas provenit arte,
Ut ſoli inceſſu faciles fluitare videntur,
Plectro morigeros qui callent fingere greſſus.
Non ſolum aſperitas teneras cave verberet aures,
Sed vox quaeque expreſſa tuae ſit mentis imago.
Lenè edat Zephyrus ſuſpiria blanda, politis
Laevius in numeris labatur laeve fluentum;
At reboat, furit, aeſtuat aemula muſa, ſonoris
Littoribus cum rauca horrendum impingitur unda.
Quando eſt ſaxum Ajax vaſtâ vi volvere adortus,
Tardè incedat verſus, multum perque laborem.
Non ita ſive Camilla cito ſalis aequora raſit,
Sive levis levitèrque terit, neque flectit ariſtas.
Audin! Timothei coeleſtia carmina, menti
Dulcibus alloquiis varics ſuadentia motus!
[67] Audin! ut alternis Lybici Jovis inclyta proles
Nunc ardet famam, ſolos nunc ſpirat amores,
Lumina nunc vivis radiantia volvere flammis,
Mox furtim ſuſpiria, mox effundere fletum!
Dum Perſae, Graecique pares ſentire tumultus
Diſcunt, victricemque lyram rex orbis adorat.
Muſica quid poterit corda ipſa fatentur, et audit
Timotheus noſtras merita cum laude Drydenus.
Tu ſervare modum ſtudeas benè cautus, et iſtos
Queis aut nil placuiſſe poteſt, aut omnia, vites.
Exiguas naſo maculas ſuſpendere noli,
Namque patent nullo ſtupor atque ſuperbia mentis
Clariùs indicio; neque mens eſt optima certè,
Non ſecus ac ſtomachus, quaecunque recuſat et odit
Omnia, difficiliſque nihil tibi concoquit unquam.
Non tamen idcirco vegeti vis ulla leporis
Te tibi ſurripiat; mirari mentis ineptae eſt,
Prudentis vero tantum optima quaeque probare.
Majores res apparent per nubila viſae,
Atque ita luminibus ſtupor ampliat omnia denſis.
His Galli minus arrident, illiſque poetae
Noſtrates, hodierni aliis, aliiſque vetuſti.
Sic
* fidei ſimile, ingenium ſectae arrogat uni
Quiſque ſuae; ſolis patet illis janua coeli
[69] Scilicet, inque malam rem caetera turba jubentur.
Fruſtra autem immenſis cupiunt imponere metam
Muneribus Divûm, atque illius tela coarctant
Solis, hyperboreas etiam qui temperat auras,
Non ſolum auſtrales genios foecundat et auget.
Qui primis laté ſua lumina ſparſit ab annis,
Illuſtrat praeſens, ſummumque accenderit oevum.
(Cuique vi [...]s variae tamen; et jam ſaecula ſoeclis
Succedunt pejora, et jam meliora peractis)
Pro meritis muſam laudare memento, nec unquam
Neglige quod novitas diſtinguit, quodve vetuſtas.
Sunt qui nil proprium in medium proferre ſuërunt,
Judiciumque ſuum credunt popularibus auris;
Tum vulgi quò exempla trahunt retrahuntque ſequuntur,
Tolluntque expoſitas latè per compita nugas.
Turba alia authorum titulos et nomina diſcit
Scriptoreſque ipſos, non ſcripta examinat. Horum
Peſſimus iſte cluet, ſi quem ſervilitèr ipſos
Viſere magnates ſtupor ambitioſus adegit.
Qui critice ad menſam domino ancillatur inepto,
Futilis ardelio, ſemper referenſque ferenſque
Nuntia nugarum. Quam pinguia, quam male nata
Carmina cenſentur, quaecunque ego fortè vel ullus
Pangere Apollineae tentat faber improbus artis!
At ſiq is vero, ſiquis vir magnus adoptet
Felicem muſam, quantus nitor ecce! venuſque
[71] Ingenio accedunt! quam prodigialitèr acer
Fit ſtubito ſtylus! omnigenam venerabile nomen
Praetexit ſacris culpam radiis, & ubique
Carmina culta nitent, & pagina parturit omnis.
Stultula plebs doctos ſtudioſa imitarier errat,
Ut docti nullos imitando ſaepius ipſi;
Qui, ſi ſorte unquam plebs rectum viderit, (illis
Tanto turba odio eſt) conſultò lumina claudunt.
Talis ſchiſmaticus Chriſti, grege ſoepe relicto,
Coelos ingenii pro laude paciſcitur ipſos.
Non deſunt quibus incertum mutatur in horas
Judicium, ſed ſemper eos ſententia ducit
U [...]tima palantes. Illis miſeranda camaena
More meretricis tractatur, nunc Dea certè,
Nunc audit vilis lupa: dum praepingue cerebrum,
Debilis & male munitae ſtationis ad inſtar,
Jam recti, jam ſtultitiae pro partibus aſtat.
Si cauſam rogites, aliquis tibi dicat eundo
Quiſque dies tenerae praebet nova pabula menti,
Et ſapimus magis atque magis. Nos docta propago
Scilicet et ſapiens proavos contemnimus omnes,
Heu! pariter noſtris temnenda nepotibus olim.
Quondam per noſtros dum turba ſcholaſtica fines
Regnavit, ſi cui quam plurima clauſula ſemper
In promptu, ille inter doctiſſimus audiit omnes;
[73] Religioſa fides ſimul ac ſacra omnia naſci
Sunt viſa in litem; ſapuit ſat nemo refelli
Ut ſe ſit paſſus. Jam gens inſulſa Scotiſtae,
Intactique abaci Thomiſtae pace fruentes
Inter araneolos pandunt ſua retia fratres.
Ipſa fides igitur cum ſit variata, quid ergo,
Quid mirum ingenium quoque ſi varia induat ora?
Naturae verique relictis finibus amens
Saepius inſanire parat popularitèr author,
Expectatque ſibi vitalem hoc nomine famam,
Suppetit uſque ſuus plebi quia riſus ineptae.
Hic ſolitus propriâ metirier omnia normâ,
Solos, qui ſecum ſunt mente et partibus iiſdem
Approbat, at vanos virtuti reddit honores,
Cui tantum ſibi ſic larvata ſuperbia plaudit.
Partium in ingenio ſtudium quoque regnat, ut aulâ,
Seditioque auget privatas publica rixas.
DRYDENO obſtabant odium atque ſuperbia nuper
Et ſtupor omnigenae latitans ſub imagine formae,
Nunc criticus, nunc bellus homo, mox deinde ſacerdos;
Attamen ingenium, joca cum ſiluêre, ſuperſtes
Vivit adhuc, namque olim utcunque ſepulta profundis
Pulchrior emerget tenebris tamen inclyta virtus.
Mllbourni, rurſus ſi fas foret ora tueri,
Blackmorique novi reducem inſequerenter; HOMERUS
Ipſe etiam erigeret vultus ſi ſorte verendos
ZOILUS ex orco greſſus revocaret. Ubique
[75] Virtuti malus, umbra velut nigra, livor adhaeret,
Sed verum ex vanâ corpus cognoſcitur umbrâ.
Ingenium, ſolis jam deficientis ad inſtar
Inviſum, oppoſiti tenebras tantum arguit orbis,
Dum claro intemerata manent ſua lumina divo.
Sol prodit cum primum, atque intolerabilè fulget
Attrahit obſcuros flammâ magnete vapores;
Mox vero pingunt etiam invida nubila callem
Multa coloratum, & creſcentia nubila ſpargunt
Uberiùs, geminoque die viridaria donant.
Tu primus meritis plaudas, nihil ipſe meretur,
Qui ſerus laudator adeſt. Brevis, heu! brevis aevi
Participes noſtri vates celebrantur, et aequum eſt
Anguſtam quam primum aſſueſcant degere vitam.
Aurea nimirum jamjudum evanuit aetas,
Cum vates patriarchae extabant mille per annos:
Jam ſpes deperiit, nobis vita altera, famae,
Noſtraque marceſcit ſexagenaria laurus!
Aſpicimus nati patriae diſpendia linguae,
Et veſtis CHAUCERI olim geſtanda DRYDENO eſt.
Sic ubi parturuit mens dives imagine multâ
Pictori, calamoque interprete coepit acuti
Concilium cerebri narrare coloribus aptis,
Protinus ad nutum novus emicat orbis, et ipſa
Evolvit manui ſeſe natura diſertae;
[77]Dulcia cum molles coeunt in faedera fuci
Tandem maturi, liquidamque decentèr obumbrant
Admiſtis lucem tenebris, et euntibus annis,
Quando opus ad ſummum perductum eſt culmen, & audent
E vivâ formae extantes ſpirare tabellâ:
Perfidus heu! pulchram color ae [...]o prodidit artem,
Egregiuſque decor jam nunc fuit omnis, et urbes,
Et fluvii, pictique homines, terraeque fuerunt!
Heu! dos ingenii, veluti quodcunque furore
Caeco proſequimur, nihil unquam muneris adfert,
Quod redimat comitem invidiam! juvenilibus annis
Nil niſi inane ſophos jactamus, et iſta voluptas
Vana, brevis, momento evanuit alitis horae!
Flos veluti veri [...] peperit quem prima juventus,
Ille viret, periitque virens ſine falce caducus.
Quid verò ingenium eſt quaeſo? Quid ut illius ergo
Tantum inſudemus? nonne eſt tibi perfida conjux
Quam dominus veſtis, vicinia tota potita eſt;
Quo placuiſſe magis nobis fors obtigit, inde
Nata magis cura eſt. Quid enim? creſcentibus almae
Muſae muneribus populi ſpes creſcit avari.
Laus ipſa acquiri eſt operoſa, et lubrica labi;
Quin quoſdam irritare neceſſe eſt; omnibus autem
Nequaquam feciſſe ſatis datur; ingeniumque
Expallet vitium, devitat conſcia virtus,
Stulti omnes oderê, ſceleſti perdere gaudent.
[79]Quando adeo infeſtam seſe ignorantia praeſtet,
Abſit, ut ingenium bello doctrina laceſſat!
Praemia propoſuit meritis olim aequa vetuſtas,
Et ſua laus etiam conatos magna ſecuta eſt;
Quanquam etenim fortis dux ſolus ovabat, at ipſis
Militibus crines pulchrae impediere corollae.
At nunc qui bifidi ſuperarunt improba montis
Culmina, certatim ſocios detrudere tentant;
Scriptorem, quid enim! dum quemque philautia ducit
Zelotypum, inſtaurant certamina mutua vates,
Et ſeſe alterni ſtultis ludibria praebent.
Fert aegrè alterius, qui peſſimus audit honores,
Improbus improbuli vice fungitur author amici;
En ſaedis quam faeda viis mortalia corda
Cogit perſequier famae maleſuada libido!
Ah! ne gloriolae uſque adeo ſitis impia regnet,
Nec critici affectans, hominis ſimul exue nomen;
Sed candor cum judicio conjuret amicè,
Peccare eſt hominum, peccanti ignoſcere, divûm.
At vero ſi cui ingenuo praecordia bilis
Non deſpumatae ſatis acri ſaece laborant,
In ſcelera accenſas pejora exerceat iras,
Nil dubitet, ſegetem praebent haec tempora largam.
Obſcaeno detur nulla indulgentia vati,
Ars licet ingenio ſupeaddita cerea flecti
[81] Pectora pelliciat. Verum, hercule, juncta ſtupori
Scripta impura pari vano molimine prorſus
Invalidam aequiparant eunuchi turpis amorem.
Tunc ubi regnavit dives cum pace voluptas
In noſtris flos iſte malus caput extulit oris.
Tunc ubi rex facilis viguit, qui ſemper amore,
Conſiliis rarò, nunquam ſe exercuit armis:
Scripſerunt mimos proceres, meretricibus aulae
Succeſſit regimen; nec non magnatibus ipſis
Affuit ingenium, ſtipendiaque ingenioſis.
Patriciae in ſcenis ſpectavit opuſcula muſae
Multa nurus, laſciva tuens, atque auribus hauſit
Omnia larvato ſecura modeſtia vultu.
Machina, virginibus quae ventilat ora, pudicum
Dedidicit clauſa officium, ad ludicra cachinnus
Increpuit, rubor ingenuus nihil amplius arſit.
Deinde ex externo traducta licentia regno
Audacis faeces Socini abſorbuit imas,
Sacrilegique ſacerdotes tum quemque docebant
Conati efficere, ut gratis paradiſon adiret;
Ut populus patriâ cum libertate ſacratis
Aſſererent ſua jura locis, ne ſcilicet unquam
(Crediderim) Omnipotens foret ipſe potentior aequo.
Templa ſacram ſatiram jam tum violata ſilebant:
Et laudes vitii, vitio mirante, ſonabant!
Accenſi hinc muſae Titanes ad aſtra ruerunt,
Legeque ſancitum quaſſit blaſphemia praelum.—
[83] Haec monſtra, O critici, contra haec convertite telum,
Huc fulmen, tonitruque ſtyli torquete ſeveri,
Et penitus totum obnixi exonerate furorem!
At tales fugias, qui, non ſine fraude ſeveri,
Scripta malam in partem, livore interprete, vertunt;
Pravis omnia prava videntur, ut omnia paſſim
Ictericus propriâ ferrugine tingit ocellus.
Jam mores critici proprios, adverte, docebo;
Dimidiata etenim eſt tibi ſola ſcientia virtus.
Non ſatis eſt ars, ingenium, doctrinaque vires,
Quaeque ſuas jungant, ſi non quoque candor honeſtis,
Et veri ſincerus amor ſermonibus inſint.
Sic tibi non ſolum quiſque amplos ſolvet honores,
Sed te, qui criticum probat, exoptabit amicum,
Mutus, quando animus dubius tibi fluctuat, eſto;
Sin tibi confidis, dictis confide pudentèr.
Quidam hebetes ſemper perſtant erroribus; at tu
Praeteritas laetus culpas fateare, dies-que
Quiſque diesredimat, criticoque examine tentet.
Hoc tibi non ſatis eſt, verum, quod praecipis, eſſe,
Veridici mala ruſticitas magè ſaepe moleſta eſt
Auribus, ingenuam quam verba ferentia fraudem;
Non ut praeceptor, cave des praecepta, reique
Ignaros, tanquam immemores, catus inſtrue: verax
[85] Ipſe placet, ſinon careat candore, nec ullos
Judicium, urbanis quod fulget moribus, urit.
Tu nulli invidias monitus, rationis avarus
Si ſis, prae reliquis ſordes miſerandus avaris.
Ne vili obſequio criticorum jura refigas,
Nec fer judicium nimis officioſus iniquum;
Prudentem haud irritabis (ne finge) monendo,
Qui laude eſt dignus patiens culpabitur idem.
Conſultum meliùs criticis foret, illa maneret
Si nunc culpandi libertas. Appius autem,
Ecce! rubet, quoties loqueris, torvoque tremendus
Intuitu, reddit ſaevi trucia ora gigantis
Jam picta in veteri magè formidanda tapete.
Fac mittas tumidum tituloque et ſtemmate ſtultum,
Cui quaedam eſt data jure licentia ſaepe ſtupendi;
Tales ad libitum vates abſque indole, eâdem,
Quâ ſine doctrinâ doctores lege creantur.
Contemptis prudens ſatiris res linque tacendas,
Aſſentatorumque infamen exerceat artem,
Nominibus libros magnis gens gnara dicandi,
Quae cum mendaci laudes effutiat ore,
Non magè credenda eſt, quam quando pejerat olim
Non iterum pingues unquam conſcribere verſus.
Non raro eſt ſatius bilem cohibere ſuëſcas,
Humanuſque ſinas hebetem ſibi plaudere: prudens
[87] Hic taceas monco, nihil indignatio prodeſt,
Feſſus eris culpando, ea gens haud ſeſſa canendo:
Nam temnens ſtimulos, tardum cum murmure curſum
Continuat, donec jam tandem, turbinis inſtar
Vapulet in torporem, & ſemper eundo queſcat.
Talibus ex lapſu vis eſt reparata frequenti,
Ut tardi titubata urgent veſtigia manni.
Horum pleraque pars, cui nulla amentia deſit,
Tinnitu numerorum et amore ſeneſcit inani,
Perſtat difficili carmen deducere venâ,
Donec inex [...]auſto reſtat faex ulla cerebro,
Relliquias ſtillat vix expreſſae malè mentis,
Et miſeram invalidâ exercet prurigine muſam.
Sunt nobis vates hoc de grege, ſed tamen idem
Affirmo, criticorum ejuſdem ſortis abunde eſt.
Helluo librorum, qui ſudat, hebetque legendo,
Cui mens nugarum doctâ farragine turget
Attentas propriae voci malè recreat aures,
Auditorque ſibi ſolus miſer ipſe videtur.
Ille omnes legit authores, omneſque laceſſit
Durſeio infeſtus pariter magnoque Drydeno.
Judice ſub tali ſemper furatur, emitve
Quiſque ſuum bonus author opus: (non Garthius illi
Si credas) proprium contexuit ipſe poema.
In ſcenis nova ſi comoedia agatur, "amicus
"Hujus ſcriptor (ait) meus eſt, cui non ego paucas
"Oſtendi maculas; ſed mens eſt nulla poetis."
[89] Non locus eſt tam ſanctus, ut hunc expellere poſſit,
Nec templum in tuto eſt, pluſquam via; quin pete ſacras
Aufugiens aras, & ad aras iſte ſequetur
Occidetque loquendo; etenim ſtultus ruet ultro
Nil metuens, ubi ferre pedem vix angelus audet.
Diffidit ſibimet ſapientia cauta, breveſque
Excurſus tentans in ſe ſua lumina vertit;
Stultitia at praeceps violento vortice currit
Nonunquam tremefacta, nec unquam e tramite cedens,
Flumine fulmineo ſe totam invicta profundit.
Tu vero quiſnam es monita inſtillare peritus,
Qui, quod ſcis, laetus monſtras, neque ſcire ſuperbis,
Non odio ductus pravove favore, nec ulli
Addictus ſectae, ut pecces, neque coecus, ut erres;
Doctus, at urbanus, ſincerus, at aulicus idem,
Audactèrque pudens mediâque humanus in irâ.
Qui nunquam dubites vel amico oſtendere culpas,
Et celebres inimicum haud parcâ laude merentem.
Purgato ingenio felix, ſed & infinito,
Et quod librorumque hominumque ſcientia ditat;
Colloquium cui come, animus ſummiſſus & ingens,
Laudandique omnes, ratio cum praecipit, ardor!
Tales extiterunt critici, quos Graecia quondam,
Romaque mirata eſt nato; melioribus annis.
Primus Ariſtoteles eſt auſus ſolvere navem,
Atque datis velis vaſtum explorare profundum.
[91] Tutus iit, longèque ignotas attigit oras
Lumina Maeoniae obſervans radiantia ſtellae.
Jam vates, gens illa, diu quae lege ſoluta eſt,
Et ſaevae capta eſt malè libertatis amore,
Laetantes dominum accipiunt, atque omnis eodem,
Qui domuit naturam, exultat praeſide muſa.
Nuſquam non grata eſt incuria comis Horatî,
Qui nec opinantes nos erudit abſque magiſtro,
Ille ſuas leges, affabilis inſtar amici
Quam veras ſimul & quam claro more profundit!
Ille licet tam judicio quam divite venâ
Maximus, audacem criticum, non ſcriptor inaudax,
Praeſtaret ſe jure, tamen ſedatus ibidem
Cenſor, ubi cecinit divino concitus aeſtro,
Carminibuſque eadem inſpirat, quae tradidit Arte.
Noſtrates homines planè in contraria currunt,
Turba, ſtylo vehemens critico, ſed frigida Phoebo:
Nec malè vertendo Flaccum torſere poetae
Abſurdi, magè quam critici ſine mente citando.
Aſpice, ut expoliat numeros Dionyſius ipſi
Maeonidae, venereſque accerſat ubique recentes!
Conditam ingenio jactat Petronius artem,
Cui doctrina ſcholas redolet ſimul & ſapit aulam.
Cum docti Fabii cumulata volumina verſas,
Optima perſpicuâ in ſerie documenta videre eſt,
[93] Haud ſecus utilia ac apothecis condimus arma,
Ordine perpetuo ſita juncturâque decorâ,
Non modo ut obtineat quo ſeſe oblectet ocellus,
Verum etiam in promptu, quando venit uſus, habenda.
Te ſolum omnigenae inſpirant, Longine, Camaenae,
Et propriam penitus tibi mentem animumque dederunt;
En! tibi propoſiti criticum fideique tenacem,
Qui vehemens ſua jura, ſed omnibus aequa miniſtrat;
Quo probat exemplo, quas tradit acumine leges,
Semper ſublimi ſublimior argumento!
Succeſſere diù ſibi tales, pulſaque fugit
Barbara praeſcriptas exoſa licentia leges.
Româ perpetuo creſcente ſcientia crevit,
Atque artes aquilarum equitâre audacibus alis;
Sed tandem ſuperata îîſdem victoribus uno
Roma triumphata eſt muſis comitantibus aevo.
Dira ſuperſtitio & comes eſt bacchata tyrannis,
Et ſimul illa animos, haec corpora ſub juga miſit.
Credita ab omnibus omnia ſunt, ſed cognita nullis,
Et ſtupor eſt auſus titulo pietatis abuti!
Obruta diluvio ſic eſt doctrina ſecundo,
Et Monachis finita Gothorum exorſa fuerunt.
At vero tandem memorabile nomen Eraſmus,
(Cuique ſacerdoti jactandus, cuique pudendus)
[95] Barbariae obnixus torrentia tempora vincit,
Atque Gothos propriis ſacros de finibus arcet.
At Leo jam rurſus viden' aurea ſecula condit,
Sertaque neglectis revireſcunt laurea muſis!
Antiquus Romae Genius de pulvere ſacro
Attollit ſublime caput. Tunc coepit amari
Sculptura atque artes ſociae, caelataque rupes
Vivere, et in pulchras lapides molleſcere formas;
Divinam harmoniam ſurgentia templa ſonabant,
Atque ſtylo & calamo Raphael & Vida vigebant;
Illuſtris vates! cui laurea ſerta poetae
Intertexta hederis critici geminata refulgent:
Jamque aequat claram tibi, Mantua, Vida Cremonam,
Utque loci, ſic ſemper erit vicinia famae.
Mox autem profugae metuentes improba muſae
Arma, Italos fines linquunt, inque Arctica migrant
Littora; ſed criticam ſibi Gallia vendicat artem.
Gens ullas leges, docilis ſervire, capeſſit,
Boiloviuſque vices domini gerit acer Horatî.
Atfortes ſpernunt praecepta externa Britanni,
Moribus indomiti quoque; nam pro jure furendi
[97] Angliacus pugnat genius, Romamque magiſtram,
Romanumque jugum ſemper contemnere pergit.
At vero jam tum non defuit unus & alter
Corda, licet tumefacta minûs, magis alta gerentes,
Ingenii partes veri ſtudioſa fovendi
Inque baſi antiquâ leges & jura locandi.
Talis, qui cecinit doctrinae exemplar & author,
"Ars bene ſcribendi naturae eſt ſumma poteſtas."
Talis Roſcommon—bonus & doctiſſimus idem,
Nobilis ingenio magè nobilitatus honeſto;
Qui Graios Latioſque authores novit ad unguem,
Dum veneres texit pudibunda induſtria privas.
Talis Walſhius ille fuit—judex & amicus
Muſarum, cenſurae aequus laudiſque miniſter,
Mitis peccantûm cenſor, vehemenſque merentûm
Laudator, cerebrum ſine mendo, & cor ſine fuco!
Haec ſaltem accipias, lacrymabilis umbra, licebit,
Haec debet mea muſa tuae munuſcula famae,
Illa eadem, infantem cujus tu fingere vocem,
Tu monſtrare viam; horridulas componere plumas
Tu ſaepe es ſolitus—duce jam miſeranda remoto
Illa breves humili excurſus molimine tentat,
Nec jam quid ſublime, quid ingens amplius audet.
Illi hoc jam ſatis eſt—ſi hinc turba indocta docetur,
Docta recognoſcit ſtudii veſtigia priſci:
[99] Cenſuram haud curat, famam mediocritèr ardet,
Culpare intrepida, at laudis tamen aequa miniſtra;
Haud ulli prudens aſſentaturve notetve;
Se demum mendis haud immunem eſſe fatetur,
At neque faſtidit limâ, quando indiget, uti.